News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Pulp mill critics pick a picnic for their protest 

Pulp mill critics pick a picnic for their protest

07 Sep, 2009 12:26 PM
MORE THAN 600 people attended a community picnic at Trevallyn Reserve yesterday organised by anti-pulp mill campaigners.

The picnic gave people the opportunity to air their concerns about the proposed use of the area for the Gunns pulp mill water pipeline.

Individuals and family groups armed with picnic rugs and camp chairs were at the reserve to hear speeches from politicians, aldermen, lobby groups and local residents.

Launceston Alderman Jeremy Ball was among those who voiced concern that public areas of the state-owned reserve would be lost because of Gunns' interests.

Alderman Ball, of Trevallyn, said he was concerned that the reserve's grassy woodlands and abundance of native birdlife that his family loved were under threat.

When a piece of land was legally created into a public reserve, it should remain a place for the public to use, he said.

Among the people who used the reserve were George and Margaret Loughborough, of Kayena - only four kilometres from the pulp mill site.

The couple used to live in Victoria's Latrobe Valley but moved to Tasmania for clean air after the Maryvale craft pulp mill was built near their home, Mr Loughborough said.

The clean air they came for was being threatened, he said.

Other speakers included TV personality Peter Cundall, TAP Into a Better Future spokesman Bob McMahon, Bass Greens MHA Kim Booth, students Kaeo Landon- Lane and Leila McMahon-Kunta, Friends of Trevallyn Reserve's Bruce Jackson and The Wilderness Society's Paul Oosting.

Gunns spokesman Matt Horan declined to comment on the event.

- James Reynolds, University of Tasmania journalism student

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
James has done a fine job with this article. However I doubt he chose the headline. The headline seems to belittle the extent of opposition to the pulp mill.
Posted by jarod beams, 7/09/2009 11:03:11 AM, on The Examiner
Jarod, if that's all you've got to complain about then you have a serious problem. It was promoted as a community picnic by the pulp mill critics themselves. So what's wrong with using the word picnic in a heading? Or is this just another case of wanting something to complain about?
Posted by Bob, 7/09/2009 12:05:26 PM, on The Examiner
Journalism students should watch out for nonsense claims when it comes to the pulp mill, like the one about moving to Tasmania due to the building of the Latrobe Valley mill in Victoria. This pulp mill was built in 1937! It is surrounded by three major towns comprising over 65,000 preople within 12 km. This mill recently upgraded to ECF bleaching and to have treated waste water released into Bass Strait, just like the Tamar Mill. Unlike in Tasmania, when the project was submitted for Commonwealth EPBC Act approval it was considered that there would be no adverse impact to any Commonwealth environmental values. Perhaps instead of picnicing next to the Forest Industries Hoo Hoo Hut, a trip to the Latrobe Valley might be more revealing to the 50 odd people in your photo!
Posted by kraft, 7/09/2009 12:35:20 PM, on The Examiner
Good point Kraft. That couple who moved to Tassie when the Latrobe Valley mill was built look pretty fit given they must be more than 100 years old. But James Reynolds isn't the only one who needs to do his homework. Alderman Ball need not worry about any impact on the Trevallyn Reserve. The Gunns pipeline at Trevallyn will be constructed entirely within a Crown land easement that already contains an Aurora overhead electricity transmission line, the Ben Lomond Water supply pipeline and a hydro pipeline. Hardly a pristine reserve! Maybe Alderman Ball should take up his concerns with those other users of the easement?
Posted by Harry, 7/09/2009 5:13:57 PM, on The Examiner
I remember when Green meant immature. Has anything changed?
Posted by Wally the worker, 7/09/2009 5:15:16 PM, on The Examiner
There are important and fundamental differences between the Latrobe Valley mill, referred to by kraft in his/her comment, and Gunns proposal. The former is operated by highly skilled and experienced experts who work for an ethical company with 72 years of detailed pulp mill knowledge. Gunns proposal is being put forward by a bunch of inexperienced woodchippers who work for a company whose ethical standards leave a lot to be desired. Secondly, the majority of the 65,000 residents of Traralgon, Morwell and Moe still experience the stench of foul gas from the mill on a daily basis despite the millions of dollars spent by PaperlinX trying to reduce odour emissions. Unlike the residents of the Tamar, all of these people have chosen to live in the midst of the odour, they have not had it forced upon them. When I interviewed the chief air monitoring officer of the Gippsland region 12 months ago he said quite bluntly that 'a new kraft pulp mill in the Latrobe valley would never be given approval under today's EPA regulations.' The people of the Tamar have every right to be angry about Gunns' proposal - it's in entirely the wrong place.
Posted by Lester Barker, 7/09/2009 8:45:00 PM, on The Examiner
I think James Reynolds has done a fine job with the story considering it was most likely his first attempt at dealing with a sensitive issue that recieves much community debate. Well done James.
Posted by rodney, 8/09/2009 11:33:52 AM, on The Examiner

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Kayena residents Margaret and George Loughborough at the protest picnic. Pictures GEOFF ROBSON
Kayena residents Margaret and George Loughborough at the protest picnic. Pictures GEOFF ROBSON
Bob McMahon and Peter Cundall.
Bob McMahon and Peter Cundall.
Bruce Jackson.
Bruce Jackson.

Most popular articles




The Examiner Newspaper







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...