News 
 Local News 
 News 
 Environment 
 Port poison: Banned in Hobart, okay at Bell Bay 

Port poison: Banned in Hobart, okay at Bell Bay

23 Jun, 2010 09:43 AM
THE toxic fumigation to take place at Bell Bay next month is not allowed at Tasports' Hobart port.

Resources Minister Bryan Green yesterday confirmed necessary buffer zones could not be enforced at the Hobart port like at Bell Bay and Burnie, where Tasports is licensed to undertake fumigations on board ships.

"It will not be allowed here in Hobart, given the proximity of rental properties and the general public," Mr Green told Parliament.

The Bell Bay fumigation of Forestry Tasmania radiata pine bound for China is expected to take place early next month.

It will end in the release of up to 1.5tonnes of methyl bromide - an ozone depleting gas, highly toxic to animals and humans.

Tasports has said it is confident the fumigation would not put its employees, other port users or the public at risk because the poisonous gas breaks down quickly.

But Bass Greens MHA Kim Booth said Mr Green's "chilling admission" was reprehensible.

Mr Booth said the Bell Bay port lay under the Tamar Valley inversion layer, which acted as a trap for airborne pollutants.

"No matter which way the prevailing wind blows, there are people located downwind from the port," Mr Booth said.

"It raises serious questions about the government's duty of care to people who live outside the capital city. "

The Wilderness Society says the controversy was further evidence an industry restructure was needed.

Society spokesman Vica Bayley said the fumigation would be averted if the timber was processed before being exported.

"Any long-term deals to export whole pine logs to China must be put on ice," he said.

Mr Bayley said it was up to the state government to intervene.

A Forestry Tasmania spokeswoman said the radiata pine destined for export was low quality and unsuitable for the local sawmillers.

She said the decision to export was made to maintain employment for contractors.

"It is not uncommon for softwood to be exported from Tasmania although Forestry Tasmania has not done so for years.

"Final details for the shipment from Bell Bay to China have not been finalised."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Fumigate the ship at Constitution Dock. in Sullivans Cove not in my back yard. I suggest the Green and Labor government politicians witness the fumigation dockside.
Posted by Geoffrey, 23/06/2010 8:48:25 AM, on The Examiner
Imagine for a second what they do to all the imports coming the other way, from China to here, and who say 'Boo!' to that (rental properties in the proximity or not..). Who's going to pay the bills if the export program is 'on ice"? Not everyone gets to live as a parasite on the taxpayer, the Primary producer is doing the right thing trying to sell this timber. Remember that it's shonky (radiata) materials we shouldn't be using- and also remeber that IF it stays here for use it needs to be doused in arsenic before it will last How does that compare to the Bromide? No better, is it?...next you'll be telling them to pick the weavils out one-by-one....are you going to fund a new improved fumigation program? No! You want to prattle and shut things down because they're in the papers...this week.
Posted by Get Real, 23/06/2010 9:35:37 AM, on The Examiner
Thats right, it's ok to poison the North East but not Hobart. They wouldn't want it in there back yard, just like the stinking pulpmill. Maybe that should be built in Huonville, on the river. Surley it wouldn't be a problem having the Dioxins down there
Posted by dl, 23/06/2010 10:08:38 AM, on The Examiner
Forestry Tasmania spokeswoman said, "the decision to export was made to maintain employment for contractors." Well, I reckon that it should be "tough titties" for the contractors when our health is threatened by assisting them to make a dollar. Let us have none of this. What says the Midnight Oil man? To date it seems to be a deafening silence! The same seems true of most of our pollies. But if Forestry Tasmania goes ahead with this foolish venture it does so at considerable peril to it's existence.
Posted by brian, 23/06/2010 10:25:28 AM, on The Examiner
Why does this Tasmanian Government constantly feel it is OK to put the residents of the Tamar Valley at risk with these pollutants but not the resident of the south? Are they even aware of the farming and wine industry community in the close proximity of the area? Or do they not even care? I agree, where is the Midnight Oil Man, how soon and easy it is to give up our principles when a pollies pay is on the line.
Posted by Concerned Tamar Resident, 23/06/2010 10:49:47 AM, on The Examiner
So Minister Green there will be sniffer equipment around the edges of the buffer zone- gas goes up doesn't it?
Posted by Carol, 23/06/2010 12:30:08 PM, on The Examiner
"It will not be allowed here in Hobart, given the proximity of rental properties and the general public," Mr Green told Parliament. So now they are going to do it in Burnie (Yes Burnie, not Bell Bay) only metres away from $1m penthouses overlooking the port. Go figure!
Posted by iReckon, 23/06/2010 12:42:06 PM, on The Examiner
The BIG PICTURE. My collegue and I have symptoms of long term exposure to suspected overseas fumigants trapped in cardboard packaging released upon opening. Rashes, hacking cough, fatigue, memory loss, blood noses, sore eyes etc. Scared for the future - Took Years to figure out...Its Getting SWEPT UNDER THE CARPET!!
Posted by sandi, 23/06/2010 1:38:46 PM, on The Examiner
Any trust that may have been created by Forestry Tasmania disappeared when I read this article. They make no financial return to the State but feel OK about subjecting us to toxic chemicals. Moving the problem doesn't make the issue any less alarming.
Posted by Launceston resident, 23/06/2010 1:52:36 PM, on The Examiner
Forestry Tasmania doesn't care who gets hurt while it continues to suck the life out of the economy.
Posted by KM, 23/06/2010 8:19:52 PM, on The Examiner
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
(1/2)
(1/2)
(2/2)
(2/2)

Most popular articles




The Examiner Newspaper







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...