Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Whistle Blower with Martin Gilmour 
 McKim outburst a step too far 

McKim outburst a step too far

POLITICIANS always tread a fine line and judgment under pressure defines the thoroughbreds from the hacks.

Judging by this week's performance, Greens leader Nick McKim is heading for the glue factory.

Everybody understands that the Greens are opposed to the proposed Bell Bay pulp mill, although the fact that they can remain part of a cabinet and government that supports the project is incongruous to most voters.

Where Mr McKim stepped over the line this week was warning away any potential investors and saying they ``would face a massive community backlash'' even before it was known whether Kiwi billionaire Richard Chandler had actually bought Gunns shares.

Now the radical elements of the environment movement and the rusted on opponents to the mill would think any attack on the project is fair game.

But in the words of Mr Chandler's senior adviser Alan Kelly: ``The pulp mill project is expected to create over 3000 jobs, significant bio-energy power generation, strong export revenues and $1 billion in state and federal taxes.''

It is supported by both houses of state and federal parliament and both major parties that represent nearly 84 per cent of voters.Mr McKim has massively underestimated the repercussions of his comments which have been widely interpreted as talking down Tasmania in the eyes of business owners, tourism operators and investors.

He must accept that perception is reality and in this case we have a member of cabinet telling investors to take their money and jobs elsewhere.

People interstate see our government as a schizophrenic mess _ divided on major issues with cabinet members having an opt-in and opt-out clause that defies parliamentary logic.

We are seen as taking more than our fair share of federal funding and failing to deliver on basics like elective surgery.

For Mr McKim, a senior partner in Labor-Green government, to proactively attack investment in Tasmania at a time when jobs and investment are scarce is a step too far.

The only thing that rates close to this is the reaction of Premier Lara Giddings who somehow read the tea leaves and blamed Will Hodgman.

Instead of addressing Mr McKim's political treason she claimed that the Liberals were playing the spoiling role.

``I'm more concerned about Will Hodgman and the Liberal Party campaign to talk Tasmania down.

``He talks about me reining in Nick McKim, I want to know how I can rein in Mr Hodgman.''

When Ms Giddings returned from holidays in late January she made it clear that Mr Hodgman was going to be one of her targets in 2012.

Strange strategy indeed to focus on your opponent when you are meant to be the policy maker and setting the agenda.

The fact remains that Ms Giddings is the Premier and one of her senior cabinet ministers has actively talked down investment in Tasmania and yet she does nothing.

If Ms Giddings thinks Will Hodgman is the problem she is in a clear state of denial.

MARTIN GILMOUR, editor

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Well done well said, I would say the majority of peole are thinking just what you said, the other issue that is of concern is the Labor party will loose the next election, the Libs will not win it, we need t see more agression, strategy, and articulation of policys from the libs, perhaps we need a better deputy LIb leader one that will back up the Leader,,
Posted by charl95, 12/02/2012 11:30:27 AM, on The Examiner
Yet even surveys commissioned by Gunns show only 37% support for this mill, 40% opposed and 23% indifferent. I voted for a major party due to their overall platform of policies but I strongly oppose the mill, people don't vote on single issues and many people who voted for a major party don't support all of their policies but make a decision that the parties overall platform is the most agreeable to their views. The numbers on jobs don't add up, Gunn's has destroyed thousands of jobs in their dogmatic pursuit of this highly unpopular inappropriately positioned pulp mill.
Posted by Rob, 12/02/2012 12:00:43 PM, on The Examiner
I believe what Mr McKim was stating to Richard Chandler was the obvious.

Yes there will be a Community backlash with regards to anyone that has in effect, given Gunns the financial licence to proceed with The Long Reach, Tamar Pulpmill.

I believe from what I have read that Sen Bob Brown, Mr McKim and Mr Booth have communicated with Richardchandler.com ,and informed him what the feelings are, of a large number of Tasmanians,e.g. Perhaps for Mr Chandler to Invest in Tasmania but not necessarily a Pulpmill by De-Facto.

.

Posted by the skipper, 12/02/2012 12:23:26 PM, on The Examiner
Martin, you have conveniently forgotten that this project was judged to be "critically non compliant" by the RPDC.
Posted by peter, 12/02/2012 12:54:06 PM, on The Examiner
McKIm and the rest of his cronies have no clue whatsoever.

For the sake of all of us and the state you need to

CALL AN ELECTION NOW !

Posted by PB, 12/02/2012 6:23:47 PM, on The Examiner
I don't live in Tasmania anymore but I follow my home state with interest. I am absolutely gobsmacked at Ms. Giddings - attacking the wrong person Lara! What are you frightened of?????
Posted by Alpen, 12/02/2012 8:13:15 PM, on The Examiner
Excellent article with some home truths that the three political leaders (and I use that term loosely) of this state should all be made to sit down and read.

Well said Martin, and yes I'm from Hobart.

Posted by paul of Hobart, 12/02/2012 8:15:29 PM, on The Examiner
iF Giddings is in de-nile the ship her off too Egypt and make take her mates the greens with her.there's more than enough sand there.

to stick their heads to escape reality economics

Posted by smokeandmirros, 13/02/2012 5:25:50 AM, on The Examiner
mr mckim has gone too far this time. what has happened to progress and jobs. are we to become a desert island ?


Posted by oldtone, 13/02/2012 9:49:21 AM, on The Examiner
Wow, McKim also gives investment advice now, is there nothing he cant do? Champion of the people, leading the way in education and the tassie prison system.

Time for an election please

Posted by BenC, 15/02/2012 8:10:01 AM, on The Examiner
1 | 2  |  next >
Whistle Blower with Martin Gilmour
The Examiner's editor, Martin Gilmour, takes a look at the issues of the day

Most popular articles




The Examiner Newspaper







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...